Kharis Templeman (祁凱立)
中文姓名:祁凱立
  • Home
  • Research
  • Teaching
  • CV
  • Blog
  • Taiwan Studies Resources

Ma Ying-jeou Claims Taiwan is an "Illiberal Democracy." Here's Why He's Wrong...

12/11/2021

0 Comments

 
Picture
​​In an editorial that came out on December 9 in Taiwan's United Daily News, former President Ma Ying-jeou called Taiwan an "illiberal democracy," blamed President Tsai Ing-wen and the DPP for taking actions that undermine freedom and the rule of law, and laid out a long list of complaints. ​(English version here).

Before I get into the rest of this, let me just say up front: no, Taiwan is not an illiberal democracy. It's as liberal, robust, and resilient as any of the Third Wave cases, and it's made major strides over the last 20 years in addressing some of its remaining democratic shortcomings, from strengthening the rights of criminal defendants to reducing the prevalence of vote-buying in elections. Ma has been hammering away at this theme for at least three years now (for instance, see here, here, here, and here), but his evidence of a DPP turn toward illiberalism in Taiwan has always been exceptionally weak, and until now I've considered this claim to be partisan political rhetoric intended solely for a domestic audience and not worth taking seriously.

​Taiwan at the Summit for Democracy
But this time is different. The Biden administration just hosted its Summit for Democracy, which has helped intensify an international debate about what democracy is, how it should be strengthened, and which countries are falling short of the democratic ideal. Taiwan got invited to the summit, and a Taiwan official, Audrey Tang, was given a prime speaking slot to talk about digital democracy. (Beijing of course did not get invited and is pretty salty about the whole thing.) The timing of this op-ed, and the fact that Ma's office has translated it into English, suggests he really does want to tap into this debate and attract the attention of a foreign audience.  

In that context, Ma's latest piece really sticks in my craw. He's asserting that the DPP government has "abandoned 'democracy' in favor of 'illiberal democracy'" and isn't a "worthy participant" in the Summit for Democracy. And yet, by most comparative measures, Taiwan's democracy is at or near the best shape it ever has been in. It has a freewheeling media ecosystem with many outlets that are highly critical of the government, frequent public demonstrations, broad protection for academic freedom and speech, and a judiciary that is far more independent of partisan politics than those in Korea, Malaysia, or Singapore. The Tsai Ing-wen administration's behavior in office is worlds apart from the illiberal tendencies of governments in Hungary or Turkey or the Philippines: nobody in Taiwan is shutting down universities or imprisoning journalists or murdering civil society activists, and that's something to celebrate, not pick at. 

I have a lot of respect for former president Ma, and I think a lot of what he accomplished during his presidency is undervalued or under-appreciated. He was certainly subject to a lot of accusations that he was destroying democracy in Taiwan, too--also mostly unwarranted. But I think he's pretty off base here.  And it's rather disappointing that he's chosen to stay involved in partisan politics like this after leaving office, rather than playing a post-partisan, elder statesman role. 

For those interested in a more detailed rebuttal, hit the jump. 

​How Democratic Is Taiwan?: The Comparative Data

​​The first thing to note is that the world's most prominent democracy indices all rate Taiwan to be a democracy, and one of the freest, most liberal and best-governed of the Third Wave democracies. So Ma is already swimming against a strong tide here. Specifically: 
  • Freedom House in 2021 rated Taiwan "free," with an overall score of 94/100--its highest rating in the history of FH, and the second-highest in Asia behind only Japan (96/100). 
  • The Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU)'s latest democracy rankings upgraded Taiwan to an overall score of 8.94/10, highest in Asia and higher for the first time than Japan (8.13) and South Korea (8.01).
  • The Bertelsmann Transformation Index has Taiwan ranked 3rd among all 137 countries it evaluates on "political transformation," with a score of 9.55/10. BTI excludes the developed democracies of western Europe and North America but includes all the third wave cases; among those only Estonia and Uruguay score higher. 
  • The Varieties of Democracy project's Liberal Democracy Index has Taiwan scored at 0.72/1, virtually identical to Japan (0.73) and slightly under South Korea (0.79).    
Moreover, three of these four have registered increases in their scores for Taiwan since Ma left office in 2016. Freedom House's score for Taiwan has risen from 89/100 in 2016 to 94/100 in 2021. The EIU's score has increased from 7.79 in 2016 to 8.94 in 2020. BTI's score was 9.55 in both 2016 and 2020. And V-Dem's LDI shows a significant improvement in Taiwan, from 0.67 in 2015 to 0.72 in 2020.  

If the DPP government is responsible for an increasingly illiberal wind blowing in Taiwan, none of the international indices are picking it up. 
Picture
Taiwan's LDI score has hit all-time highs during the Tsai era (2016-present)

​Illiberal Actions?

​Nevertheless, Ma Ying-jeou knows Taiwan politics much better than the typical coder for one of these organizations, so perhaps he's picking up on serious violations of the rule of law or democratic norms and practices that they're missing. That's the case he makes in his op-ed, citing nine instances when the DPP government or President Tsai behaved in an "illiberal" manner. I'll take these one by one:   

1. On January 5, 2018, Professor Kuan Chung-ming was elected as the President of National Taiwan University, but the Ministry of Education ignored the legitimacy of the election and violated the "University Act" by denying his eligibility. It took more than a year for Professor Kuan to finally be appointed.

The missing context here, for those who don't follow Taiwan politics closely, is that the NTU election itself was controversial because of an apparent conflict of interest of one of the electors, along with Kuan's KMT affiliation and previous service in the Ma administration. Kuan's (mostly pan-green) opponents at the school then dug up some other accusations against him, including plagiarism charges, violation of a rule against teaching in the PRC, and writing paid columns for a media outlet while he was a government minister. The MoE refused to approve his appointment until those questions were addressed. Kuan was ultimately cleared of the plagiarism accusations, and the issue was finally resolved when the Minister of Education, Yeh Jiunn-rong, himself an NTU professor on leave and former colleague of Kuan's, threw himself on his sword by appointing Kuan president and then immediately resigning. Kuan is still president of NTU today. If this was a strike against academic freedom, as Ma claims, it was ultimately beaten back. 

(As a US-trained academic, I find the Taiwanese system of faculty directly electing the university president a bit bewildering, given how vicious and petty academic politics can be, but that's beside the point.)

2. On September 12, 2018, media reports revealed that Chang Tien-chin, the deputy chairman of the Transitional Justice Commission regarded the Commission as a sort of "Dong Chang (a secret police agency in ancient China)" and used "transitional justice" as a tool to attack Hou Yu-ih, the KMT candidate for mayor of New Taipei City.

This comment was clearly inappropriate, and Chang Tien-chin quickly resigned after it became public. The TJC hasn't actually gone after Hou You-yi at all, and he remains one of the most popular mayors in Taiwan at the moment. 

3. On June 17, 2019, the DDP [sic] caucus in the Legislative Yuan amended the "Referendum Act" at President Tsai’s request to do away with the previous practice of holding referendums on the same days as general elections. The amended act mandated that referendums would instead be held on the fourth Saturday of August every two years. It is perfectly obvious that this change will reduce voter participation in referendums.

The reason the DPP changed the Referendum Act is because holding it concurrently with other elections in 2018 resulted in a lot of confusion and long lines to vote. There's a good administrative reason to separate them. It's also worth remembering here that the DPP used to be the party pushing for holding referendums concurrently with other elections, to juice up their turnout, and the KMT was opposed. 

4. On December 19, 2019, Su Hung-dah, a Professor in the Department of Political Science at National Taiwan University, criticized the government's cultural policy. The Taipei City Police Department then called him in for questioning regarding a possible violation of the "Social Order Maintenance Act." He was interrogated for several hours at a police station.

Clearly inappropriate action by the Taipei city police, in hindsight. But context, again: this was the month before the 2020 president election, when there was deep fear of a surge in CCP-backed disinformation flooding Taiwanese media. This case ended up being exceptional, rather than the start of a crackdown on free speech. This long piece by Nick Aspinwall does an excellent job of describing the challenges of responding to false charges during this period.

5. On August 28, 2020, President Tsai, acting without discussion with the Executive Yuan or the Legislative Yuan, unilaterally announced a decision to allow the import of highly controversial American ractopamine pork (including offal).

Now this is rather silly coming from Ma, who did the same thing in 2009 when he was president. The difference with Tsai? Ma's own KMT caucus overruled him, joining the DPP to overturn Ma's executive order and impose a ban on ractopamine-fed beef imports. Tsai has a better handle on her own party caucus and has kept them in line behind her decision (though it hasn't been easy.) There's lots of hypocrisy in both parties on the ractopamine issue. But the bottom line is, in a representative democracy leaders sometimes have to make tough choices that go against public opinion. That's not anti-democratic, or illiberal. The voters will get their chance to weigh in soon enough.  

6. On December 11, 2020, President Tsai shut down CTi News, which was the first time that a Taiwanese TV news station had ever been shut down by the government in history.

It's more accurate to say the National Communication Commission (NCC) made this decision, not Tsai Ing-wen herself. The NCC is supposed to operate as an independent commission, though its members are appointed by the president. I have mixed feelings about this action, which we explored in a Hoover event last March. But it is clearly defensible. I noted in that post that (1) CtiTV had some serious ethical problems and had been linked to the CCP's United Front propaganda efforts; (2) it had repeatedly violated the terms of its license; (3) it continues to broadcast via YouTube; and (4) all the other pan-blue channels have remained on the air. Also, here's the Reporters without Borders position on this case: "The non-renewal of CTi news channel's licence [sic] does not go against press freedom." 

7. On March 28, 2021, President Tsai ignored the results of the 2018 referendum in which the people of Taiwan voted to retain nuclear power. She insisted on taking the fuel rods of the Fourth Nuclear Power Plant and sending them abroad.

Yes, the Tsai government ignored the result because it legally could: the Referendum Act does not have a self-execution clause. This is a problem with the referendum law, as I noted here. A similar thing happened with same-sex marriage, which voters banned. The legislature (rightly, in my view) ignored that vote to comply with a Constitutional Court ruling. If your main complaint is about the poor design of Taiwan's referendum system, I'd agree with you...but the changes to the Referendum Act certainly don't support the case that Taiwan is growing more illiberal. I mean, the DPP itself first lowered the Referendum Act threshold in 2017 to make citizen-initiated referendums more feasible. C'mon, man.   

8. On November 16, 2021, President Tsai personally designated the DDP [sic] mayoral candidates, thereby essentially abolishing a nomination system in the DDP [sic] that had been in existence for decades.

This is a non-sequitur: as E.E. Schattschneider noted long ago, intra-party democracy is not a necessary condition for a regime to be democratic. Also, this is not a new thing: Tsai as DPP chairwoman has exercised considerable influence over the party's nominations since 2008. It helped the DPP recover in 2009-10, be competitive in 2012, and win big in 2014 and 2016. There's nothing inherently authoritarian about a party delegating to its leader the ability to choose nominees. 
​
9. In November 2021, the media disclosed that a female DPP legislator was violently abused by her boyfriend. The report resulted in the exposure of the DPP's "cyber army" system. These cyber armies, which are suspected of receiving support from a questionable source, are like "online brownshirts" who have long bullied anyone that disagrees with the government on the Internet. In fact, they have even hounded an outstanding Taiwanese diplomat stationed in Japan to death.

This is a long-standing complaint from KMT folks, dating back to before the 2020 presidential campaign. I'm not sure what Ma means by "exposed" here, or a "questionable source," or really what online "cyber armies" have to do with the Kao Chia-yu case. What I do know is that there's a lot of harassment online, it targets people of all political stripes, and it's an ongoing problem not just in Taiwan but in most democracies. That doesn't make Taiwan "illiberal," it makes it normal these days.    

​​All things considered, this list of "illiberal actions" is pretty weak tea. There will always be some friction in democracies about where the balance should be struck between competing rights, values, and interests. Most of these actions fall in that gray area and reflect the normal give and take of politics and governance, not a drift toward illiberalism in Taiwan.  
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    About Me

    I am a political scientist with research interests in democratization, elections and election management, parties and party system development, one-party dominance, and the links between domestic politics and external security issues. My regional expertise is in East Asia, with special focus on Taiwan.

    Posting on Bluesky @kharist.bsky.social

    Archives

    April 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    November 2024
    October 2024
    May 2024
    March 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    August 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    December 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    September 2019
    August 2019
    November 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    October 2017
    August 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013

    Categories

    All
    1992 Elections
    2008 Elections
    2012 Elections
    2014 Elections
    2016 Elections
    2020 Elections
    2022 Elections
    2024 Elections
    Aacs
    Aborigines
    AI
    Alex Tsai
    Alicia Wang
    Annette Lu
    Announcements
    Apsa
    Apsa Cgots
    Arthur P Wolf
    Artificial Intelligence
    Blog Meta
    Book Review
    Brookings Institution
    Campaign Regulation
    CCP
    CDDRL
    CEC
    Chang Ching Chung
    Chang Chun Hsiung
    Chang Jung-wei
    Chang Li-shan
    Chang Ming-ta
    Chang Sho-wen
    Chen Che-nan
    Chen Chien-nian
    Chen Chi Mai
    Chen Chin-te
    Chen Ding-nan
    Chen Fu-hai
    Cheng Chao-fang
    Cheng Cheng-ling
    Cheng Pao-ching
    Chen Kuang-fu
    Chen Kuan-ting
    Chen Ming-wen
    Chen Ou-pu
    Chen Shih Chung
    Chen Shih-chung
    Chen Shui Bian
    Chen Tsang-chiang
    Chen Wan-hui
    Chen Wei-chung
    Chen Ying
    Chen Yu-chen
    Chiang Chi Chen
    Chiang Chi-chen
    Chiang Ching Kuo
    Chiang Jui-hsiung
    Chiang-kai-shek
    Chiang Tsung-yuan
    Chiang Wan-an
    Chin Hui Chu
    Chou Chiang-chieh
    Chou Chun-mi
    Chou Hui-huang
    Chuang Suo Hang
    Chung Chia-pin
    Chung Tung-chin
    Citizen 1985
    Civil Society
    Conferences
    Control Yuan
    Council Of Grand Justices
    Cross-party-negotiating-committee
    Cross Strait Relations
    CSSTA
    Defense Spending
    Demography
    Developmental State
    Diplomacy
    Disinformation
    DPP
    DPP Policy Papers
    Eats
    Economic Security
    Economic Voting
    Electoral Geography
    Electoral Reform
    Electoral Systems Wonkery
    Energy Policy
    Eric Chu
    Executive Yuan
    Fan Yun
    Fellowship
    Frank Hsieh
    Freddy Lim
    Frida Tsai
    Fu Kun Chi
    Fu Kun-chi
    Germany
    Han Kuo Yu
    Han Kuo-yu
    Hau Lung Bin
    Hau Pei Tsun
    Henry Rowen
    Ho Kan-ming
    Hoover Institution
    Housing
    Hou You Yi
    Hou You-yi
    Hsiao Bi Khim
    Hsiao Bi-khim
    Hsieh Fu-hung
    Hsieh Kuo-liang
    Hsieh Lung-chieh
    Hsieh Sam Chung
    Hsu Chen-wei
    Hsu Chih-jung
    Hsu Chung-hsin
    Hsu Hsin-ying
    Hsu Shu-hua
    Hsu Ting-chen
    Huang Hong-cheng
    Huang Kuo Chang
    Huang Kuo-chang
    Huang Min-hui
    Huang Shan Shan
    Huang Shan-shan
    Huang Shih Ming
    Huang Shiou-fang
    Huang Wei-che
    Huang Yung-chin
    Human Rights
    Hung Hsiu Chu
    Hung Tzu Yung
    Hung Tzu-yung
    Influence Operations
    In Memoriam
    Internship
    James Soong
    Japan
    Jiang Yi Huah
    Job Market
    John Chiang
    John Wu
    Journal Of Democracy
    Kao Hung-an
    Kawlo Iyun Pacidal
    Ker Chien Ming
    KMT
    Kmt History
    Ko Chih-en
    Kolas Yotaka
    Ko Wen Je
    Lai Ching Te
    Lai Ching-te
    Lai Feng-wei
    Lai Hsiang-ling
    Lee Chin-yung
    Lee Chun Yi
    Lee Chun-yi
    Lee Teng-hui
    Legal-wonkery
    Legislative Yuan
    Liang-kuo-shu
    Liang Su Jung
    Lien Chan
    Lii Wen
    Lin Chia-lung
    Lin Chih-chien
    Lin Fei-fan
    Lin Geng-ren
    Lin Hung Chih
    Lin Ming-chen
    Lin Tsung-hsien
    Lin Zi Miao
    Lin Zi-miao
    Liu Chao-hao
    Liu Cheng-ying
    Liu Chien-kuo
    Liu Kuo Tsai
    Lo Chih Cheng
    Lu Hsiu Yi
    Lu Shiow-yen
    Martial Law
    Ma Vs Wang
    Ma Ying Jeou
    Media
    Media Freedom
    Min Kuo Tang
    Nationalism
    Natsa
    NCC
    New Power Party
    Nuclear Power
    Occupy LY
    Pingpuzu
    Political Economy
    Political Science
    PRC
    PTIP
    Publications
    Public Opinion
    Quality Of Democracy
    Ramon Myers
    Rao Ching-ling
    ROC Constitution
    Russia
    Saidai Tarovecahe
    Sean Lien
    Security Studies
    Semiconductor Industry
    Shen Hui-hung
    Shen Lyu Shun
    Simon Chang
    Song Kuo-ting
    South Korea
    Speaker Series
    Stanford
    Statistics
    Street Protests
    Su Ching-chuan
    Su Huan-chih
    Su Jia Chyuan
    Su Jia-chyuan
    Sunflower Movement
    Su Tseng-chang
    Taiwanese Economy
    Taiwan Journal Of Democracy
    Taiwan People's Party
    Taiwan Rural Front
    Taiwan Solidary Union
    Taiwan Studies
    Taiwan World Congress
    Terry Gou
    Testimony
    The Diplomat
    This Week In Taiwan
    Ting Shou Chung
    Trade Relations
    Trans Pacific Partnership
    Tsai Chi-chang
    Tsai Ing Wen
    Tsai Shih-ying
    Tsao Chi-hung
    Tsao Er-yuan
    Tseng Yung Chuan
    Tzu Chi
    Ukraine
    United Nations
    Uscc
    US Taiwan NextGen
    Us Taiwan Relations
    V-dem
    Wang Chien-hsien
    Wang Chung-ming
    Wang Huei-mei
    Wang Jin Pyng
    Wang Mei-hui
    Wan Mei-ling
    Wei Yao Kan
    Wellington Koo
    Weng Chang-liang
    Wild Lily Movement
    Wilson Center
    Wu Den Yi
    Wu Yung Hsiung
    Xi Jinping
    Yang Cheng-wu
    Yang Shi-chiu
    Yang Wen-ke
    Yang Yao
    Yao Eng-chi
    Yao Wen-chih
    Yosi Takun
    You Si-kun
    Yu Shyi Kun

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.